Ice(d) Scent Space Kit

Milk Expressive is the sweet spot for me: creamy woody-tonka with a soft marshmallow vibe that stays cozy without turning sharp or weird. Milk Bold surprised me in the best way: stronger, still smooth, and the marshmallow stays “nice” even after a couple hours. Milk Personal was much lighter and leaned a bit clean/lotiony with a slight powder vibe on my blotter, so it’s not my favorite. Overall, great set for finding your preferred Milk intensity and style.

I‘ve seen reviews describing this as a cheap scent.

I would not agree. Usually, I am not a fan of sweet scents. To me, this isn‘t cloying at all, but warm - like a hug, like getting in from the cold and warming up with a lovely warm cup of spiced milk.

Though I have to say - not a summer fragrance, at least for me it only works during the colder seasons.

Paper by Commodity fragrances has beautiful notes of ink, amber, wood, rain, moss and earthy vetiver. All three fragrances in this discovery set have their own uses. I love them all equally, and they all dry down to slightly different intensity of scents.

Gold Expressive is the version I’d actually wear: creamy vanilla warmth with a smooth woody base and good presence. Gold Personal was cozy but very subtle on my blotter and started to feel a little dry as it wore on. Gold+ Bold wasn’t for me; I found it too smoky, so I gave it away. If you like warm vanilla/amber scents, the set is a solid way to figure out which Gold profile fits your style before buying.

Commodity discovery sets are excellent. The design is minimalist and just like the rest of the brand. They generous samples with decent atomizers. Plus, you get a coupon code for the value of the kit. Book unfortunately was not for me. That makes me so glad that this kit was accessible!

Velvet is smooth, warm, and quietly seductive. It wraps soft florals in creamy woods and a gentle musk, feeling cozy rather than loud. Elegant, intimate, and grown—this is a close-to-the-skin scent that feels like confidence, not performance. The half star is definitely noteworthy, definitely not a favorite like milk or gold but deserves recognize as a surprise stand out.

I bought this at the same time as the large discovery set, I was a little disappointed to see what juice replaced velvet in that set (turns out I loved juice anyway!) and wasn’t due to get this sample set just for velvet. Don’t question it, just get it! Velvet is one of my favourites now

I'm glad I picked up Commodity’s Juice Discovery Set, even though the scents just weren’t my vibe. Nothing was bad at all—they’re clearly high quality and well made, just not what I usually reach for.

That said, this set was perfect for testing everything out without committing to a full bottle. I really liked being able to try them on my skin and see how they wore throughout the day. It did exactly what a discovery set should do and helped me narrow down what I like (and don’t). Totally worth it if you’re curious about the Juice line or want to avoid a blind buy.